In the fascinating world of complex characters, Charioce XVII / Chris from Shingeki no Bahamut: VIRGIN SOUL emerges as an intriguing figure who combines elements of self-discipline, determination, and adaptability—essential characteristics of Stoicism. Through his relationship with Nina, Charioce illustrates how love can be both a source of weakness and strength, depending on how it is managed. This analysis will explore how Charioce embodies and challenges Stoic principles, offering a deep insight into his evolution as a character.
To fully appreciate this reflection, it is recommended to have watched the series and read previous analyses on it from my blog, as this will allow for a more detailed understanding of how Charioce XVII presents himself as a modern Stoic, facing challenges and growing throughout the narrative. His complexity and development are deeply tied to his context in the series, and understanding his motivations and actions is crucial for analyzing his Stoicism.
Charioce XVII / Chris is a complex character who embodies several Stoic principles, although his behavior does not fully align with traditional Stoic principles. His strong self-discipline and determination in pursuing power and justice align with the teachings of Epictetus, who emphasizes focusing on what one can control and acting with virtue. However, his relationship with Nina introduces an emotional element that could be considered a weakness in a traditional Stoic context. Nonetheless, Charioce demonstrates that his love for Nina does not distract him from his primary objectives; instead, it motivates him to be better and protect her, suggesting a balance between reason and emotions.
In this sense, Charioce maintains a Stoic attitude toward adversity, similar to Seneca's teachings on indifference to passions. Although he acknowledges his sadness over losing his sight, he does not succumb to despair. His love for Nina is a positive emotion that does not necessarily oppose Stoic principles, as it can be seen as a form of rational love. This is reflected in how Charioce presents himself differently to Nina, showing a more human and vulnerable side without losing his internal coherence.
Acceptance of fate is another Stoic aspect in Charioce. Although he does not passively accept fate, his ability to adapt to circumstances is notable. His relationship with Nina can be seen as a form of accepting fate, as his love for her is something he cannot fully control but accepts and values. This aligns with the concept of "Amor Fati" (love of fate), where one accepts and loves what happens to them. Charioce, by accepting his love for Nina as part of his life, shows a form of Stoic acceptance of fate.
Charioce has a strong sense of purpose centered on elevating humanity. His love for Nina can be seen as a form of virtue, as it motivates him to be better and protect her. This aligns with the idea that love can be a virtue if kept within the bounds of reason and virtue. His determination to protect Nina is a motivating force for his virtuous actions, reinforcing his commitment to a higher cause.
The relationship between Charioce and Nina also introduces a weakness in his resolution, but it can also be seen as a strength, as it motivates him to be better and act with virtue. Although love can be viewed as a weakness in a traditional Stoic context, it can also be a source of strength if maintained within the limits of reason and virtue. Charioce manages his emotions so they do not interfere with his purpose, demonstrating a form of Stoic self-discipline.
The use of symbols like the red chili pepper and the cornicello, which Charioce gives to Nina, represents love and protection. This can be seen as a form of self-discipline, where Charioce chooses to show different facets of himself depending on the situation. His ability to adapt to different situations and people while maintaining his internal coherence is a Stoic characteristic that reflects Marco Aurelius's teaching on adapting to changes with wisdom.
Charioce is willing to make sacrifices for his mission and for Nina, which aligns with the Stoic idea that one should be willing to sacrifice personal interests for the greater good. His love for Nina motivates him to make sacrifices he would not have considered before, showing how love can guide his virtuous decisions. In episode 17, Charioce admits that Nina is the only person who has made him question his actions, suggesting he is willing to reconsider his actions for her.
Self-reflection is another Stoic trait Charioce demonstrates throughout the story. By recognizing that Nina is his weakness, he shows an ability to reflect on his own emotions and limitations. Although traditional Stoicism promotes indifference to emotions, Charioce accepts his feelings for Nina as part of his human experience, demonstrating a form of authentic Stoicism.
Living in the present is a Stoic principle that Charioce also illustrates. By focusing on the conversations and moments he shares with Nina in the present, he shows a Stoic focus on the here and now. This is reflected in how he values each moment with Nina without lamenting what he has lost.
The appearance of Azazel's black feathers in Shingeki no Bahamut VIRGIN SOUL Blu-ray Amazon.co.jp Complete Volume Purchase Bonus Drama CD 'With Nina' from suggests an act of forgiveness and reconciliation, adding a theme of redemption to the dialogue. Charioce seeks internal and external reconciliation, reflecting his personal growth.
The paradox of control and freedom is interesting in Charioce. Although his love for Nina can be seen as a limitation, it also motivates him to act with virtue and protect her, reinforcing his sense of internal freedom. This paradox illustrates how freedom can be exercised even in adverse situations, aligning with Stoic teachings on freedom as the ability to choose how to respond to circumstances.
Finally, Charioce's relationship with power and virtue is complex. While his pursuit of power may seem contradictory to Stoic principles, his love for Nina motivates him to act with virtue, suggesting that power can be used for good if aligned with reason and virtue. This reinforces the idea that Charioce, despite not fully aligning with traditional Stoic principles, shows a capacity for growth and reflection worthy of consideration. His love for Nina can be seen as a form of rational and virtuous love that motivates him to act with virtue and protect her, aligning with some aspects of Stoicism.
Now that we have explored how Charioce XVII / Chris embodies and challenges Stoic principles, I invite you to delve deeper into his complex personality. We will analyze how his determination and self-discipline intertwine with his ability to love and protect Nina, and how this reflects a balance between reason and emotions. We will explore how his leadership and use of power can be seen as a form of Stoic virtue, and how his relationship with fate and acceptance of change define him as a modern Stoic character.
Join ONIKIRIMARU on this journey of discovery and reflection about Stoicism in Shingeki no Bahamut VIRGIN SOUL, and share your own perspectives on how Charioce XVII / Chris presents himself as a model of Stoicism in the contemporary era!
THE POWER OF LOVE AS A STOIC VIRTUE
To deepen the analysis of Charioce XVII / Chris as a Stoic, it is important to consider several Stoic points and reflections, including famous quotes from Epictetus, Seneca, and Marcus Aurelius, as well as relevant dialogues from the series Shingeki no Bahamut VIRGIN SOUL.
I. Self-Discipline and Determination
Charioce shows strong self-discipline and determination in his pursuit of power and justice. This aligns with the teachings of Epictetus, who emphasizes the importance of focusing on what one can control and acting with virtue. Despite his blindness, Charioce continues to rule and rebuild his kingdom, demonstrating his unwavering determination.
- Stoic Quote:
- Epictetus: "Happiness and freedom begin with a clear understanding of a principle: some things are under our control and others are not" (Epictetus, Discourses).Charioce focuses on what he can control, such as his leadership and political decisions.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In the analysis of episode 15, Charioce tells Nina that she is the reason he continues forward, showing how his love for her motivates him to continue with his mission.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 17, Charioce admits that Nina has given him a reason to live, despite the sacrifice he plans to make for her and his kingdom. This demonstrates his determination and ability to find motivation in his personal relationships.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Focus on what is controllable: Charioce focuses on his political and military objectives, demonstrating his ability to distinguish between what he can control and what he cannot.
- Perseverance: Despite obstacles, Charioce continues working toward his goals, showing Stoic determination.
Charioce maintains a Stoic attitude toward adversity, reminiscent of Seneca's teachings on indifference to passions. Although he acknowledges his sadness over losing his sight, he does not succumb to despair.
- Stoic Quote:
- Seneca: "We often fear more than we suffer; and we suffer more in imagination than in reality" (Seneca, Letters to Lucilius).Charioce faces his negative emotions with a realistic perspective, without letting his imagination dominate him.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce jokes about making Nina his consort, which initially upsets her because she thinks he is not taking her seriously. However, he quickly apologizes and acknowledges his feelings, showing control over his emotions and consideration for her.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 20, Charioce presents himself differently to Nina, showing a more human and vulnerable side without losing his internal coherence.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Emotional control: Charioce rarely shows negative emotions, suggesting control over his passions.
- Focus on reason: His decision-making is guided by reason and strategy rather than emotions.
Charioce does not passively accept fate, but his ability to adapt to circumstances is notable. His blindness and Nina's silence are significant challenges for their relationship, but both learn to communicate and connect in new ways.
- Stoic Quote:
- Epictetus: "Do not try to make events happen as you wish; rather, wish that they happen as they do and you will be happy" (Epictetus, Discourses).Charioce accepts his blindness and adapts to it, finding new ways to interact with Nina.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In episode 24, Charioce mentions that he now perceives time differently and that his sense of hearing has improved, demonstrating his ability to adapt to his new reality.
- Concrete Example:
- In "With Nina," Charioce reflects on how his blindness has allowed him to appreciate Nina's voice more, showing a positive adaptation to his condition.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Strategic flexibility: Charioce adjusts his plans according to circumstances, demonstrating his ability to adapt.
- Focus on what can be controlled: Although he does not passively accept fate, he focuses on what he can influence.
- Stoic Quote:
- Marcus Aurelius: "Do not waste more time arguing about what a good man should be. Be one" (Marcus Aurelius, Meditations).Charioce acts according to his principles, even when facing personal challenges, and tries to be the best version of himself.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce reflects on rebuilding the Orleans cavalry squadron, showing his commitment to the well-being of his kingdom and people.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 15, Charioce strives to protect Nina, showing that his love for her is a motivating force for his virtuous actions.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Commitment to a cause: Charioce is deeply committed to his vision of justice, reflecting a sense of personal virtue.
- Pursuing the greater good: Although his interpretation of the greater good may be questioned, his dedication to a superior cause is a Stoic characteristic.
- Stoic Quote:
- Seneca: "Where there is a human being, there is an opportunity for kindness" (Seneca, Letters to Lucilius).Charioce shows kindness and compassion toward Nina, demonstrating a form of Stoic virtue.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce invites Nina to dance, suggesting a deep emotional connection that transcends physical and communicative barriers.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 20, Charioce presents himself differently to Nina, showing a more human and vulnerable side without losing his internal coherence.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Capacity for rational love: Although Charioce develops feelings for Nina, these do not distract him from his primary objectives; he continues to love her without wavering.
- Emotional management: Charioce manages his emotions so they do not interfere with his purpose.
- Stoic Quote:
- Epictetus: "You become what you give your attention to" (Epictetus, Discourses).Charioce focuses on his relationship with Nina and his purpose, reflecting his personal growth.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce mentions that the servants now accept Nina in the palace, symbolizing her growing importance in his life and her acceptance by his inner circle.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 17, Charioce admits that Nina is the first person who has made him question his actions, demonstrating a capacity to reflect on his own emotional weaknesses.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Flexibility in interaction: Charioce adapts to different situations and people, showing an ability to change his behavior without losing his purpose.
- Internal coherence: Although he shows different facets, Charioce maintains internal coherence in his values and objectives.
- Stoic Quote:
- Marcus Aurelius: "Loss is nothing but change, and change is the delight of nature" (Marcus Aurelius, Meditations).Charioce accepts his blindness as a natural change and finds new ways to interact with Nina.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce initially rejects Nina's help with eating but later yields and asks her to cut his meat, showing a gradual acceptance of his dependence on her.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 24, Charioce mentions that his blindness has allowed him to appreciate Nina's voice more, demonstrating a positive adaptation to his condition.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Acceptance of limitations: Charioce accepts his blindness as a consequence of his actions, showing a form of Stoic acceptance of fate.
- Recognition of others' help: Although he is an independent character, Charioce recognizes the importance of Nina's help, demonstrating an ability to accept support from others in times of need.
- Stoic Quote:
- Seneca: "True happiness is to enjoy the present, without anxiously depending on the future" (Seneca, Letters to Lucilius).Charioce focuses on the conversations and moments he shares with Nina in the present.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce focuses on the conversations and moments he shares with Nina in the present, rather than lamenting what he has lost.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 20, Charioce invites Nina to dance, suggesting a deep emotional connection that transcends physical and communicative barriers.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Focus on the present: Charioce focuses on the conversations and moments he shares with Nina in the present.
- Acceptance of the present: Charioce accepts current circumstances and seeks to find meaning in them.
- Stoic Quote:
- Epictetus: "Do not worry about what others think of you, but about what you think of yourself" (Epictetus, Discourses).Charioce seeks internal and external reconciliation, reflecting his personal growth.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," the mention of the black feathers is interpreted as a sign that Azazel has forgiven Charioce for his actions, indicating a theme of reconciliation and redemption in the story.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 24, Charioce reflects on his past and how he has changed thanks to Nina, suggesting a process of self-reflection and personal forgiveness.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Harmony with the environment: He seeks harmony and balance in his environment, contributing to his own inner peace.
- Facing the past: He recognizes his past and seeks a way to reconcile with it, allowing him to move forward with a renewed perspective.
- Stoic Quote:
- Seneca: "Virtue is the greatest good, because it is the good that makes us happy" (Seneca, Letters to Lucilius).Charioce seeks virtue through his commitment to his cause and his love for Nina.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In episode 17, Charioce tells Nina that he is willing to sacrifice everything for her and his kingdom, demonstrating his commitment to his mission and his love.
- Concrete Example:
- In "With Nina," Charioce mentions that his love for Nina is what motivates him to move forward, even in adversity.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Commitment to a cause: Charioce is willing to sacrifice his personal well-being for his vision of justice and for Nina.
- Love as motivation: His love for Nina is a motivation for his virtuous actions and sacrifices.
XI: Recognition of Weaknesses
Charioce recognizes that Nina is his weakness, but instead of rejecting it, he accepts and values it.
- Stoic Quote:
- Epictetus: "Do not worry about what does not depend on you, but about what does depend on you" (Epictetus, Discourses).Charioce accepts his weaknesses and focuses on what he can control.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In episode 17, Charioce admits that Nina is the first person who has made him question his actions, demonstrating a capacity to recognize and accept his own emotional weaknesses.
- Concrete Example:
- In "With Nina," Charioce apologizes for not being able to see Nina in her dragon form as he admired her with such wonder in episode 4, showing an acceptance of his physical and emotional limitations.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Self-reflection: Charioce shows an ability to reflect on his own weaknesses and emotions.
- Acceptance of emotions: Although traditional Stoicism promotes indifference to emotions, Charioce accepts his feelings for Nina as part of his human experience.
XII: Acceptance of Limitations
Charioce accepts his blindness as a consequence of his actions, demonstrating a form of Stoic acceptance of fate.
- Stoic Quote:
- Marcus Aurelius: "Adversity reveals the character of men" (Marcus Aurelius, Meditations).Charioce faces his limitations with courage and determination.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce mentions that his blindness has allowed him to appreciate Nina's voice more, demonstrating a positive adaptation to his condition.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 24, Charioce focuses on conversations with Nina, showing how he has learned to value what he can experience through other senses.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Acceptance of limitations: Charioce accepts his blindness as a consequence of his actions, showing a form of Stoic acceptance of fate.
- Positive adaptation: Although he faces challenges, Charioce finds ways to adapt and appreciate what he has.
XIII: Focus on Virtue
Charioce has a strong sense of virtue centered on elevating humanity. His love for Nina can be seen as a form of virtue, as it motivates him to be better and protect her.
- Stoic Quote:
- Epictetus: "Virtue is the greatest good and the basis of all other goods" (Epictetus, Discourses).Charioce seeks virtue through his political ambition and his love for Nina.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce reflects on rebuilding the Orleans cavalry squadron, showing his commitment to the well-being of his kingdom and people.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 15, Charioce strives to protect Nina, showing that his love for her is a motivating force for his virtuous actions.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Commitment to a cause: Charioce is deeply committed to his vision of justice, reflecting a sense of personal virtue.
- Pursuing the greater good: Although his interpretation of the greater good may be questioned, his dedication to a superior cause is a Stoic characteristic.
XIV: Pursuing the Greater Good
Charioce seeks the greater good through his political ambition, although his method may be questionable. His love for Nina motivates him to act with virtue and protect her.
- Stoic Quote:
- Seneca: "The greatest good is to live in accordance with nature" (Seneca, Letters to Lucilius).Charioce seeks to live in accordance with his nature and purpose, even in adversity.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In episode 17, Charioce tells Nina that she is the reason he continues forward, showing how his love for her motivates him to continue with his mission.
- Concrete Example:
- In "With Nina," Charioce mentions that his love for Nina is what motivates him to move forward, even in adversity.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Commitment to a cause: Charioce is willing to sacrifice his personal well-being for his vision of justice and for Nina.
- Love as motivation: His love for Nina is a motivation for his virtuous actions and sacrifices.
XV: Love as Virtue
The love Charioce feels for Nina can be seen as a virtue, as it motivates him to be better and protect her.
- Stoic Quote:
- Seneca: "Love is a virtue, not a vice" (Seneca, Letters to Lucilius).Charioce demonstrates a form of love that motivates him to act with virtue.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce invites Nina to dance, suggesting a deep emotional connection that transcends physical and communicative barriers.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 20, Charioce presents himself differently to Nina, showing a more human and vulnerable side without losing his internal coherence.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Capacity for rational love: Although Charioce develops feelings for Nina, these do not distract him from his primary objectives.
- Emotional management: Charioce manages his emotions so they do not interfere with his purpose.
XVI: Flexibility in Interaction
Charioce adapts to different situations and people, showing an ability to change his behavior without losing his purpose.
- Stoic Quote:
- Marcus Aurelius: "Life is a series of changes, and we must adapt to them with wisdom" (Marcus Aurelius, Meditations).Charioce adapts to changing circumstances, maintaining his internal coherence.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce mentions that the servants now accept Nina in the palace, symbolizing her growing importance in his life and her acceptance by his inner circle.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 17, Charioce admits that Nina is the first person who has made him question his actions, demonstrating a capacity to reflect on his own emotional weaknesses.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Flexibility in interaction: Charioce adapts to different situations and people, showing an ability to change his behavior without losing his purpose.
- Internal coherence: Although he shows different facets, Charioce maintains internal coherence in his values and objectives.
XVII: Internal Coherence
Although Charioce shows different facets of his personality, he maintains internal coherence in his values and objectives.
- Stoic Quote:
- Epictetus: "Do not worry about what others think of you, but about what you think of yourself" (Epictetus, Discourses).Charioce focuses on his own internal coherence and personal values.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce apologizes for not being able to see Nina in her dragon form, showing an acceptance of his physical and emotional limitations.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 24, Charioce focuses on conversations with Nina, showing how he has learned to value what he can experience through other senses.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Internal coherence: Although he shows different facets, Charioce maintains internal coherence in his values and objectives.
- Authenticity: Charioce is authentic in his actions and emotions, reflecting a form of Stoic authenticity.
- Stoic Quote:
- Seneca: "Life is very brief and should not be wasted" (Seneca, Letters to Lucilius).Charioce values each moment with Nina and seeks to make the most of the time he has.
- Dialogue from the Story:
- In "With Nina," Charioce mentions that his blindness has allowed him to appreciate Nina's voice more, demonstrating a positive adaptation to his condition.
- Concrete Example:
- In episode 20, Charioce invites Nina to dance, suggesting a deep emotional connection that transcends physical and communicative barriers.
- Reasons he is considered Stoic:
- Appreciation for life: Charioce values life and the relationships he has formed, especially with Nina.
- Positive adaptation: Although he faces challenges, Charioce finds ways to adapt and appreciate what he has.
- Epictetus. (2014). Discourses (R. Hard, trans.). Oxford University Press.
- Seneca. (1969). Letters to Lucilius (R. Campbell, trans.). Penguin Books.
- Marcus Aurelius. (1997). Meditations (G. Long, trans.). Dover Publications.
- Onikirimaru.com. (n.d.). Analysis of Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul episodes. Retrieved from https://www.onikirimaru.com/
- Albertochavarino.com. (n.d.). Collection of Stoic quotes. Retrieved from https://www.albertochavarino.com/
- Culturainquieta.com. (n.d.). Collection of Stoic quotes. Retrieved from https://www.culturainquieta.com/
- Elestoico.com. (n.d.). Collection of Stoic quotes. Retrieved from https://www.elestoico.com/
Post a Comment